Photo Credit: Getty Images
As anticipation builds for Horizon: An American Saga — Chapter 2, a lawsuit has surfaced that casts a long shadow over the film's production. Filed on May 27, 2025, by veteran stunt performer Devyn LaBella, the complaint accuses Kevin Costner of orchestrating an unscripted, violent scene during filming—a claim his legal team vehemently denies.
According to the 34-year-old's legal filing, the incident took place on May 2, 2023, on a Utah set. LaBella alleges that she was subjected to a non-consensual and unplanned rape scene under Costner's direction, describing the experience as both traumatic and professionally isolating. "I was left exposed, unprotected, and deeply betrayed by a system that promised safety," she told The Hollywood Reporter, stating that the incident fundamentally altered her relationship with the industry.
LaBella, whose résumé includes Barbie, Yellowjackets, and CSI: Vegas, claims she was not rehired for Horizon 3, which began filming in early 2024. Her lawsuit outlines allegations of sexual discrimination, harassment, and a hostile work environment. The suit also emphasizes her emotional fallout—shock, humiliation, and a sense of abandonment.
Kevin Costner, 70, has denied the allegations through his attorney, Marty Singer, who characterized the claims as "absolutely without merit." In a statement shared with Us Weekly, Singer stated, "Kevin Costner always prioritizes safety and professionalism on set. These accusations contradict not only Kevin's values but LaBella's own actions."
To support this, Singer released screenshots of text messages purportedly sent by LaBella after a rehearsal dinner, attended by her supervisor, the stunt coordinator, and an assistant. The texts, shared with media outlets, allegedly contain friendly messages and emojis. Singer also noted that LaBella continued working on the film for several weeks afterward and even organized a thank-you dinner for the stunt coordinator.
The public response to the suit has been sharply divided. While some argue that post-incident behavior doesn't negate potential wrongdoing, others question the timeline and LaBella's continued engagement with the production. The legal process will likely hinge on contextual interpretations and the reliability of digital communications as evidence.
As Horizon 2 readies for its Venice Film Festival premiere, the unfolding lawsuit forces a broader conversation about power, consent, and accountability in film. Whether Costner's reputation emerges unscathed or altered, the case raises critical questions about on-set standards and the systems meant to uphold them.
